When it comes to modern coins, grading is everything. Collectors chase perfection — and in today’s market, that often means MS70. Set registries reward it, collectors brag about it, and the premiums can be huge. Even an MS69 can command a solid price when demand is high.

But what about an MS68?

In the modern world, an MS68 can feel like the stepchild of the hobby — not quite perfect, not even close to registry-worthy, and often dismissed as “less than.” The question is: should it be?

If we’re talking about a common bullion or proof coin with tens of thousands of perfect 70s out there — then yes, an MS68 is usually a tough sell. Collectors chasing registry points or visual perfection won’t stop at 68. The difference in price can be shocking, and the market often treats it like a raw coin.

However, context matters. If you’re looking at a low-mintage issue — maybe only 100 or so total struck — the story changes. When supply is that tight, even an MS68 can represent one of the finest known. In those cases, a 68 could actually be a sleeper pick, especially if the coin has eye appeal and scarcity on its side.

So is MS68 the kiss of death?
Not always. It depends on what the coin is, how many exist, and who might want it down the line.

At Scarsdale Coin, we always remind collectors that grade is only one part of the story. Mintage, eye appeal, and long-term desirability often matter just as much — sometimes more.

Would you ever buy a modern MS68? Or is it a deal-breaker no matter what? Let’s hear your take — drop a comment or stop by the shop to talk coins!