Reviews

Scarsdale Coin
5
Reviews

WHAT OUR CLIENTS HAVE TO SAY.

JOHN MABEN

These guys are tops, experts to the experts. Trust them when buying or selling!

JOHN MABEN

These guys are tops, experts to the experts. Trust them when buying or selling!

Shop Now

ANTHONY BARGNESI

Awesome dealer. I'm at the New Hampshire coin expo, giving the best deals of all.

ANTHONY BARGNESI

Awesome dealer. I'm at the New Hampshire coin expo, giving the best deals of all.

Shop Now

ANDREW COLES

Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!

ANDREW COLES

Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!

Shop Now

ZACHARY KELMAN

Honest, trustworthy, and dependable! Best place to buy and sell!! Will do more business!

ZACHARY KELMAN

Honest, trustworthy, and dependable! Best place to buy and sell!! Will do more business!

Shop Now

KEVEN SEPE

Very fair and knowledgeable. I recommend them.

KEVIN SEPE

Very fair and knowledgeable. I recommend them.

Shop Now

JAMES S.

A++
A first class person to do business with.

JAMES S.

A++
A first class person to do business with.

Shop Now

KENNETH WEDER

A superior medallion & supremely packaged I highly recommend this seller!

KENNETH WEDER

A superior medallion & supremely packaged I highly recommend this seller!

Shop Now

MATT

Awesome!! Even better than advertised!!! Buy from with total confidence!!! A++++

MATT

Awesome!! Even better than advertised!!! Buy from with total confidence!!! A++++

Shop Now

JIMMY PORKCHOP

These Guys know their stuff. Also they are very courteous. They pay you in cash right on the spot. I've been all around Westchester & The Bronx. They pay more & are very Honest & Trustworthy...

JIMMY PORKCHOP

I sold some coins & bills to them about 3yrs & 3mos ago & they gave me great deals on all my stuff. Great bunch of Guys & Gals. God Bless them All!!

Shop Now

DAVID SHEFFERMAN

After I left an inquiry by voicemail, Jon called me back almost immediately and addressed my questions clearly and honestly. My subsequent business with him was very professional:...

DAVID SHEFFERMAN

friendly, efficient, and fair. I highly recommend Jon and Scarsdale Coin whether you're interested in buying, selling, or appraising coins or precious metals. Thanks again, Jon!

Shop Now

ANTHONY JOHNSON

I needed some cash quick so I decided to sell some silver coins that I had a few weeks ago. I collect silver coins and did not want to sell my collection to a pawn shop because I knew they would not pay me that much. The owner at Scarsdale...

ANTHONY JOHNSON

Coin was nice to talk to and he definitely gave me a fair price for my coins. Since he did right for me, I wanted to pass along a good review to him.

Shop Now

MICHAEL

Good afternoon Jon, The coin arrived today - it's magnificent! It honestly looks even better in hand - great original surfaces and excellent detail - just the way it should look. I am very pleased with it...

MICHAEL

, it would be a pleasure to do more business with you.

Shop Now

FRANK NARDONE

Jon is an extremely polite and professional coin dealer. His fairness and prompt service were very appreciated by my sister Carol. He is a pleasure to conduct business with on all counts! Highly recommended.

FRANK NARDONE

Shop Now

TOP NOTCH TONERS AND COINS

I’ve dealt with Jon on a few occasions. Since we spoke electronically, his communication is always swift and direct. My questions are always accompanied with a pleasurable...

TOP NOTCH TONERS AND COINS

greeting. When it is time to buy or sell I use Scarsdale. Hopefully, I’ll be able to stop in person soon.

Shop Now

RONALD REIDER

I wanted to sell a large collection of coins I had inherited and kept for about 30 years. Jon, the owner of Scarsdale Coin provided just what I needed -- an estimated price over the phone which became the final price when we met.

RONALD REIDER

No haggling, no dismissing portions of the collection, and I did not have to drag the coins all over Manhattan or Westchester, because we met at the train station in Scarsdale

Shop Now

JONATHAN

I recently inherited some coins from my Grandfather. I emailed Jon and he emailed me within 15 minutes and gave me his professional judgement about what to do with them. I am glad Jon was there to help me understand...

JONATHAN

the collection my Grandfather had. I recommend people reach out first via email because I am sure Jon will get back to you as soon as possible!

Shop Now

STAN S.

I received the Franklin half in the mail today Thank you so very much. This was much more than I expected I thank you again so very much!

STAN S.

I received the Franklin half in the mail today Thank you so very much. This was much more than I expected I thank you again so very much!

Shop Now

STEVEN C.

I recently contacted Jon for his assistance with a coin collection from an estate I had agreed to manage. There were about 300 coins, and Jon had the...

STEVEN C.

patience to wade through them. He offered a vary fair price and took the whole set. He is trustworthy and a pleasure to deal with.

Shop Now

ANDREW COLES

Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!

ANDREW COLES

Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!

Shop Now

GREGORY S.

I want to thank you for sticking to the deal when you could have sold at least some of the items to the bank. You're a man of integrity.

GREGORY S.

I want to thank you for sticking to the deal when you could have sold at least some of the items to the bank. You're a man of integrity.

Shop Now

CYNTHIA M.

I think john is the only real coin expert in Westchester. I had been left some coins and didn't know what they were worth. John was...

CYNTHIA M.

great, offered me a great amount. Other stores seem only to be interested in buying them for as little as possible. Highly recommend him

Shop Now

NICK BOYD

100% professional. Knowledge and honest are a hard combination to find in this world, Scarsdale Coin is a great choice. Do business here. You won't be disappointed!

NICK BOYD

100% professional. Knowledge and honest are a hard combination to find in this world, Scarsdale Coin is a great choice. Do business here. You won't be disappointed!

Shop Now

SF CROWBIRD K.

I had a hobo coin and Jon Lerner is extremely knowledgable about this type of coin. He responded very quickly and paid right away. I will be doing business with him again.

SF CROWBIRD K.

I had a hobo coin and Jon Lerner is extremely knowledgable about this type of coin. He responded very quickly and paid right away. I will be doing business with him again.

Shop Now

KEN L.

This is exactly what I wanted and it came just as advertised. Thank you for a great product and all the original packaging that you sent with it, is in perfect condition. Thank you!

KEN L.

This is exactly what I wanted and it came just as advertised. Thank you for a great product and all the original packaging that you sent with it, is in perfect condition. Thank you!

Shop Now

JIMMY R.

Jon I had to send you this note and please feel free to use my name ... Before meeting with you regarding my Fathers collection I went and visted the three coin stores in Westchester. I never got a good feeling from them...

JIMMY R.

they all wanted to buy my coins and the price they offered was similiar. However I appreciate that you took the time to actually study my Fathers collection and found the brass ring which meant that your offer of $7,500 was almost double what the stores offered me. Thank you so much!!!

Shop Now

RICHARD S.

Scarsdale Coin Store is much more than a great coin shop: I find them to be honest, up front, fair, helpful and incredible knowledgeable. I always see a smile on Jon's face, and he's willing to talk and teach without being in a hurry...

RICHARD S.

and super super super knowledgeable about coins.Trust me when I tell you, if you want to buy, sell or just browse a good selection of coins and more this is the place. This is my go to place for all things coins, gold and silver. I have bought from this shop on several occasions.

Shop Now

TRAVIS Y.

I went to Scarsdale coin because I inherited a collection of coins just recently. A lot of the places I went to would give me quotes of very low prices on the coins, and it just didn't seem right to me. I ended up taking my coins here...

TRAVIS Y.

and while the prices they quoted me were much higher they also gave me some very good explanations as to why each coin was worth what it was. So they really know their stuff. If you have some coins you want to know more about I definitely suggest checking these guys out.

Shop Now

PHIL G.

Jon,I reached out to a dealer friend of mine, who carefully examined the holder, and he determined that at some point the holder must have been dropped. There is no indication of any fraud with regard to replacing the...

PHIL G.

original coin in the holder. The coin is too nice. I wish to thank you for your willingness to hear my story, and offer your assistance. I have decided not to send the coin out for re-slabbing/CAC.By the way my dealer friend said that you have a very good reputation. I just wanted you to know that.

Shop Now

JOSEPH S.

Over the years I have asked many dealers and collectors and had never met someone wiling to share information and as knowledgeable as you" "Thank you for sharing your wisdom with me

JOSEPH S.

Over the years I have asked many dealers and collectors and had never met someone wiling to share information and as knowledgeable as you" "Thank you for sharing your wisdom with me

Shop Now

EVERETT B.

Hi Jon, Got my Trime today and am quite pleased with it. The subtle reverse toning with the pastel colors was a pleasant surprise. Thank you for the fast ship, and for a first purchase from you was satisfied completely. I hope to make...

EVERETT B.

other purchases as my budget allows and will continue to check your inventory for examples for my type set. Thanks again,

Shop Now

MICHAEL L.

Thank You Jon, Your trust in my honesty and fair business practice is exactly what is missing in so many business relationships. I handle situations with my company the same way as well. It will be a pleasure to continue doing business...

MICHAEL L.

with you again. Please include my name on any mailings and keep me informed of any additional coin or collectable offerings. Best regards,

Shop Now

JACK M.

Jonathan is very knowledgeable about the products he represents. Quality and service oriented. (This customer rated you highly for professionalism, responsiveness, and value)

JACK M.

Jonathan is very knowledgeable about the products he represents. Quality and service oriented. (This customer rated you highly for professionalism, responsiveness, and value)

Shop Now