Reviews

READ OUR REVIEWS AND YOU CAN SEE JUST HOW SERIOUSLY WE TAKE COIN COLLECTING.
We would love for you to read our reviews! Serious numismatist or amateur hobbyist, you’ll find everything you need for coin collecting here at Scarsdale Coin – the recognized leader in buying and selling coins.
Scarsdale Coin is a proud partner of PCGS, NGC and PMG and our customers leave great reviews because they know they can trust us. That’s why they return to Scarsdale Coin again and again.
If you have purchased a coin from us, or asked for an appraisal we would love to hear from you! We encourage our customers to visit our contact page to leave reviews and we’ll be sure to respond! Also, be sure to look at our Coin Show Calendar for important dates and times and come see us!

Jon Lerner
President & Founder
Read Our RevieWS And HEar WHAT OUR CLIENTS HAVE TO SAY.
JOHN MABEN
These guys are tops, experts to the experts. Trust them when buying or selling!
ANTHONY BARGNESI
Awesome dealer. I'm at the New Hampshire coin expo, giving the best deals of all.
ANTHONY BARGNESI
Awesome dealer. I'm at the New Hampshire coin expo, giving the best deals of all.
ANDREW COLES
Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!
ANDREW COLES
Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!
ZACHARY KELMAN
Honest, trustworthy, and dependable! Best place to buy and sell!! Will do more business!
ZACHARY KELMAN
Honest, trustworthy, and dependable! Best place to buy and sell!! Will do more business!
KEVEN SEPE
JAMES S.
A first class person to do business with.
KENNETH WEDER
MATT
JIMMY PORKCHOP
These Guys know their stuff. Also they are very courteous. They pay you in cash right on the spot. I've been all around Westchester & The Bronx. They pay more & are very Honest & Trustworthy...
JIMMY PORKCHOP
I sold some coins & bills to them about 3yrs & 3mos ago & they gave me great deals on all my stuff. Great bunch of Guys & Gals. God Bless them All!!
DAVID SHEFFERMAN
After I left an inquiry by voicemail, Jon called me back almost immediately and addressed my questions clearly and honestly. My subsequent business with him was very professional:...
DAVID SHEFFERMAN
friendly, efficient, and fair. I highly recommend Jon and Scarsdale Coin whether you're interested in buying, selling, or appraising coins or precious metals. Thanks again, Jon!
ANTHONY JOHNSON
ANTHONY JOHNSON
MICHAEL
FRANK NARDONE
FRANK NARDONE
TOP NOTCH TONERS AND COINS
TOP NOTCH TONERS AND COINS
RONALD REIDER
RONALD REIDER
JONATHAN
JONATHAN
STAN S.
STAN S.
STEVEN C.
STEVEN C.
ANDREW COLES
Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!
ANDREW COLES
Jon couldn't be more professional. He is honest, fair, and a pleasure to deal with. I look forward to working with Jon again!
GREGORY S.
GREGORY S.
CYNTHIA M.
I think john is the only real coin expert in Westchester. I had been left some coins and didn't know what they were worth. John was...
CYNTHIA M.
great, offered me a great amount. Other stores seem only to be interested in buying them for as little as possible. Highly recommend him
NICK BOYD
100% professional. Knowledge and honest are a hard combination to find in this world, Scarsdale Coin is a great choice. Do business here. You won't be disappointed!
NICK BOYD
SF CROWBIRD K.
I had a hobo coin and Jon Lerner is extremely knowledgable about this type of coin. He responded very quickly and paid right away. I will be doing business with him again.
SF CROWBIRD K.
KEN L.
This is exactly what I wanted and it came just as advertised. Thank you for a great product and all the original packaging that you sent with it, is in perfect condition. Thank you!
KEN L.
JIMMY R.
Jon I had to send you this note and please feel free to use my name ... Before meeting with you regarding my Fathers collection I went and visted the three coin stores in Westchester. I never got a good feeling from them...
JIMMY R.
RICHARD S.
Scarsdale Coin Store is much more than a great coin shop: I find them to be honest, up front, fair, helpful and incredible knowledgeable. I always see a smile on Jon's face, and he's willing to talk and teach without being in a hurry...
RICHARD S.
TRAVIS Y.
I went to Scarsdale coin because I inherited a collection of coins just recently. A lot of the places I went to would give me quotes of very low prices on the coins, and it just didn't seem right to me. I ended up taking my coins here...
TRAVIS Y.
and while the prices they quoted me were much higher they also gave me some very good explanations as to why each coin was worth what it was. So they really know their stuff. If you have some coins you want to know more about I definitely suggest checking these guys out.
PHIL G.
Jon,I reached out to a dealer friend of mine, who carefully examined the holder, and he determined that at some point the holder must have been dropped. There is no indication of any fraud with regard to replacing the...
PHIL G.
JOSEPH S.
JOSEPH S.
EVERETT B.
EVERETT B.
MICHAEL L.
MICHAEL L.
JACK M.
Jonathan is very knowledgeable about the products he represents. Quality and service oriented. (This customer rated you highly for professionalism, responsiveness, and value)
JACK M.
CHRIS
Thanks for the beautiful coins. And for the prompt mailing!
MIKE
NICELY DETAILED VAM, JUST AS PROMISED. THANKS MUCH
BARRY HEATH
Beautiful Coin, pleased in every way...
Would You Like To Leave A Review? Email Us About Your Experience →